The Urgent Need to Defend DEI: Why Philanthropy Must Lead Against the Backlash
In 2024, states across the country introduced more than 40 bills to limit DEI programs in higher education, corporate spaces, and philanthropy. More recently, the Trump administration escalated federal threats against DEI efforts, framing them as "reverse discrimination." This growing assault on DEI is not just political rhetoric—it is a direct effort to dismantle decades of civil rights progress and maintain systemic inequities.
Philanthropy must meet this moment with conviction and urgency—not just by defending DEI, but by expanding it as a strategic and moral imperative. If philanthropy remains silent, it risks being complicit in the rollback of equity and justice.
The Need for DEI
DEI is deeply rooted in the legacy of the Civil Rights Movement, reinforced by landmark legislation such as the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and the Equal Employment Opportunity Act of 1965. While these laws established protections, systemic disparities remain entrenched—particularly for historically marginalized communities.
The racial wealth gap is at its widest. Black families hold only 10% of the wealth of white families, while Latino families hold just 20% (U.S. Census Bureau)—a direct result of historical exclusion from homeownership, education, and employment opportunities.
Gender disparities exacerbate economic inequities. Black women earn just 64 cents for every dollar earned by white, non-Hispanic men, while Hispanic women earn only 57 cents (Center for American Progress). These gaps are not accidental—they reflect deeply embedded barriers to economic mobility.
Philanthropy is not exempt from these inequities. In 2024, philanthropic giving exceeded $550 billion, yet less than 7% of this funding reached BIPOC-led and -serving nonprofits—despite these communities comprising 41% of the U.S. population and facing the greatest disparities.
Moreover, the staff and leadership of philanthropic institutions do not reflect the diversity of the communities they serve:
These disparities are not incidental—they are symptoms of a systemic failure in philanthropy’s leadership and funding structures. DEI is essential to dismantling these barriers, ensuring equitable funding practices, and supporting leaders from underrepresented backgrounds who are best positioned to serve their communities.
When DEI Falls Short: Strengthening Efforts for Lasting Change
While DEI is necessary for addressing systemic inequities, pro-DEI advocates acknowledge that many initiatives fall short in execution and impact. A major critique is that DEI often becomes a checkbox exercise, prioritizing symbolic gestures over structural change. Many organizations implement one-time bias training or diverse hiring initiatives without addressing wage disparities, leadership barriers, or workplace cultures that marginalize underrepresented employees. Additionally, the lack of accountability and measurable outcomes makes it difficult to determine whether DEI efforts lead to real progress or simply serve as public relations tools.
Another concern is DEI fatigue and short-term commitments. Many institutions launched DEI initiatives in response to public outcry—such as after the murder of George Floyd—only to scale them back once media attention faded. DEI officers frequently face institutional resistance, limited resources, and high burnout rates, leading to stalled progress or outright rollbacks. Without systemic policy changes, sustainable investment, and leadership accountability, DEI risks becoming performative rather than transformative.
For philanthropy to drive meaningful change, DEI must go beyond representation and training and tackle economic justice, systemic inequities, and structural barriers that continue to exclude marginalized communities.
The Scapegoating and Weaponizing of DEI
The growing backlash against DEI distorts these initiatives, falsely framing them as threats to meritocracy and social cohesion.
President Donald Trump and other anti-DEI advocates have weaponized rhetoric to portray DEI as a politically motivated distraction that prioritizes identity over merit. Their claims that DEI fosters reverse discrimination are deliberate misrepresentations, obscuring the fact that these initiatives address longstanding systemic barriers to opportunity.
Some critics argue that DEI initiatives create division by emphasizing differences rather than unity. However, this argument overlooks the fact that true inclusion does not happen by ignoring inequities—it happens by addressing them head-on. The alternative to DEI is not meritocracy, but a continuation of exclusionary systems that have long privileged certain groups over others.
The Trump Administration’s Assault on DEI
Beyond rhetoric, the Trump administration has escalated its assault on DEI, using legal threats and policy changes to dismantle these programs in both corporate and nonprofit sectors. Their tactics of coercion include:
Lawsuits and federal investigations targeting companies and institutions that maintain DEI programs.
Threats to revoke federal funding for organizations that uphold DEI initiatives.
Misusing the Civil Rights Act to claim that DEI constitutes "illegal discrimination"—a blatant misinterpretation of laws designed to protect marginalized groups.
This legal intimidation is not about fairness—it is a calculated effort to stifle progress and deepen societal divisions. If successful, these efforts could erase decades of civil rights gains and further entrench systemic inequities.
The Moral Imperative for Philanthropic Leaders
Philanthropy has long been a force for social change—providing critical support to the Civil Rights Movement and advancing global human rights. This is another defining moment.
To counter this backlash, philanthropic leaders must take deliberate, measurable actions:
Tie DEI to Grantmaking – Increase unrestricted funding to BIPOC-led organizations
Advocate Publicly – Use the power of philanthropy’s platforms to speak out against anti-DEI legislation and disinformation campaigns.
Protect DEI Leaders – Invest in legal and financial protections for DEI practitioners and ensure their work is not undermined by institutional resistance.
Strengthen Internal DEI Metrics – Move beyond demographic quotas to assess how philanthropy influences pay equity, leadership pathways, and funding equity.
The future of DEI in philanthropy is not just about resisting attacks—it is about deepening its impact and ensuring its long-term viability.
Conclusion: A Defining Moment for Philanthropy
The fight for DEI mirrors past civil rights struggles—and today, philanthropy stands at a crossroads.
Will we succumb to fear and division, aligning with those who seek to preserve inequity? Or will we stand firm, defending justice, equity, and opportunity for all?
History is watching. Just as leaders once stood against segregation, we must now resist efforts to dismantle DEI.
We must advocate for a society where every individual—regardless of race, gender, or background—has the opportunity to thrive.
The choice is clear. The time to act is now.
References
Chow, B. (2018). From Words to Action: A Practical Philanthropic Guide to Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion.
Council on Foundations. (2024). 2024 Grantmaker salary and benefits report: Key findings. Council on Foundations. https://cof.org/content/2024-grantmaker-salary-and-benefits-report-key-findings
Danziger, P. (2025, January 24). Costco shareholders overwhelmingly support company's DEI policies as other major retailers retreat. Forbes. https://www.forbes.com/sites/pamdanziger/2025/01/24/costco-shareholders-overwhelmingly-support-companys-dei-policies-as-other-major-retailers-retreat/
Fortune. (2024, April 10). JPMorgan's Jamie Dimon on racial equity gap and $30 billion commitment. Fortune. https://fortune.com/2024/04/10/jpmorgan-jamie-dimon-racial-equity-gap-30-billion/
Fortune. (2025, January 29). Companies like Costco and Apple are defending their DEI programs despite nationwide pushback—These are the companies standing by their policies. Fortune. https://fortune.com/2025/01/29/companies-like-costco-and-apple-are-defending-their-dei-programs-despite-nationwide-pushback-these-are-the-companies-standing-by-their-policies/
Fox Business. (2025, January 23). Companies like Costco and Apple are defending their DEI programs despite nationwide pushback—These are the companies standing by their policies. Fox Business. https://www.foxbusiness.com
Fox News. (2025, January 23). Trump's dismantling of DEI is deeper and bigger than you even know. Fox News. https://www.foxnews.com/opinion/trumps-dismantling-dei-deeper-bigger-than-you-even-know
Gonzalez, M. (2025, January 23). Trump's dismantling of DEI is deeper and bigger than you even know. Fox News. https://www.foxnews.com/opinion/trumps-dismantling-dei-deeper-bigger-than-you-even-know
JPMorgan Chase. (2020). JPMorgan Chase announces $30 billion commitment to advance racial equity. JPMorgan Chase. https://www.jpmorganchase.com
Kelly, J. (2025, January 23). JPMorgan's Jamie Dimon stands firm amid conservative pressure to dismantle DEI initiatives. Forbes. https://www.forbes.com/sites/jackkelly/2025/01/23/jpmorgans-jamie-dimon-stands-firm-amid-conservative-pressure-to-dismantle-dei-initiatives/
Murray, C. (2025, January 28). DEI under fire: Trump eliminates diversity program in military—Here’s a list of major organizations dropping DEI. Forbes. https://www.forbes.com/sites/conormurray/2025/01/28/dei-under-fire-trump-eliminates-diversity-program-in-military-heres-a-list-of-major-organizations-dropping-dei/
National Urban League. (n.d.). Demand diversity: Roundtable to convene in response to incoming administration’s threat to DEI. National Urban League. https://nul.org/news/demand-diversity-roundtable-convene-response-incoming-administrations-threat-dei
National Women’s Law Center. (2017). The wage gap: The who, how, and why behind the gender wage gap. National Women’s Law Center. https://nwlc.org
Pew Research Center. (2023). Latino wealth gaps persist despite years of progress. Pew Research Center. https://www.pewresearch.org
The White House. (2025, January). Ending illegal discrimination and restoring merit-based opportunity. The White House. https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/01/ending-illegal-discrimination-and-restoring-merit-based-opportunity/
Time. (2025, January). What is DEI? Trump executive order and companies’ diversity efforts. Time. https://time.com/7210039/what-is-dei-trump-executive-order-companies-diversity-efforts/
U.S. Census Bureau. (2024). Income and poverty in the United States: 2023. U.S. Census Bureau. https://www.census.gov
